§ 20-spørgsmål S 1792 Om rapporten »Human Rights and Migration«.

Af: Morten Messerschmidt (DF)
Til: Justitsminister Nick Hækkerup (S)
Dato: 16-09-2020
Samling: 2019-20
Status: Tilbagetaget

Om § 20-spørgsmålet

Sagsgang:
Anmeldelse 16-09-2020
Spørgsmålets ordlyd:
Vil ministeren kommentere rapporten »Human Rights and Migration« af den norske professor Ole Gjems-Onstad, idet der især udbedes en vurdering af afsnittet om udpegningen af dommere ved Den Europæiske Menneskerettighedsdomstol, hvor der blandt andet skrives om den norske dommer: »at the same time his judgements at the Norwegian Supreme Court and his many publications on human rights law reveal that Mr. Bårdsen is the most maximalist human rights judge the Norwegian Supreme Court has ever seen. He has penned some strong minority votes and in later lectures and articles has openly criticised the »other side« in decisions of the Court in which he has been involved. Such criticism is not especially common among Norwegian Supreme Court judges. Bårdsen has also been quite public in advocating an expansionist attitude to the application of human rights law«?
Skriftlig begrundelse:
Ingen.

§ 20-spørgsmål

Dokumentdato: 16-09-2020
Modtaget: 16-09-2020
Omdelt: 16-09-2020

Vil ministeren kommentere rapporten »Human Rights and Migration« af den norske professor Ole Gjems-Onstad, idet der især udbedes en vurdering af afsnittet om udpegningen af dommere ved Den Europæiske Menneskerettighedsdomstol, hvor der blandt andet skrives om den norske dommer: »at the same time his judgements at the Norwegian Supreme Court and his many publications on human rights law reveal that Mr. Bårdsen is the most maximalist human rights judge the Norwegian Supreme Court has ever seen. He has penned some strong minority votes and in later lectures and articles has openly criticised the »other side« in decisions of the Court in which he has been involved. Such criticism is not especially common among Norwegian Supreme Court judges. Bårdsen has also been quite public in advocating an expansionist attitude to the application of human rights law«?

Vil ministeren kommentere rapporten »Human Rights and Migration« af den norske professor Ole Gjems-Onstad, idet der især udbedes en vurdering af afsnittet om udpegningen af dommere ved Den Europæiske Menneskerettighedsdomstol, hvor der blandt andet skrives om den norske dommer: »at the same time his judgements at the Norwegian Supreme Court and his many publications on human rights law reveal that Mr. Bårdsen is the most maximalist human rights judge the Norwegian Supreme Court has ever seen. He has penned some strong minority votes and in later lectures and articles has openly criticised the »other side« in decisions of the Court in which he has been involved. Such criticism is not especially common among Norwegian Supreme Court judges. Bårdsen has also been quite public in advocating an expansionist attitude to the application of human rights law«? (pdf-version)
Html-version